What should you do before you reply?

Put the phone down and find the job. Google's advice for bad reviews includes checking your records, and that saves you from the worst reply there is: a confident denial to a customer you did in fact let down.

  1. Find the job by name, street and date.
  2. Ask whoever was on site what happened.
  3. Decide which part, if any, was your fault.
  4. If it looks fake or abusive, report it as well as replying.

What should a reply say?

The reply has two readers. The first is the customer, who may or may not come back. The second is everyone who looks you up next, who is deciding whether to ring you.

Google's guidance comes down to this: be polite and clear, keep it short, be honest, admit mistakes that were yours without taking the blame for things outside your control, show some empathy and sign it. Which? adds two useful points: stay "emotionally neutral", and move the conversation offline when it needs more than a line or two. In practice that gives you four short lines:

Four lines that cover most bad reviews
LineWhat it doesFor example
1. AcknowledgeShows you read it"Sorry to read this, Neil."
2. Be honestOwns what was yours and nothing more"You should have had a call, and you didn't."
3. Offer a next stepTakes it off the page"Please ring me on [number]."
4. Sign itPuts a person behind the firm"Dave"

Example replies for trades

We wrote these for this guide. The reviews and names are made up, so change the details to match what really happened. If you can't honestly say a line, take it out.

You turned up late

Review: Said 9am, arrived gone 11. No call, no text. Took a morning off work for nothing.

Reply: Sorry about that, Karen. You should have had a call as soon as we knew we were running late, and you didn't. That's on us, and we've changed how we let customers know. If there's anything still to sort on the job, ring me on [number]. Dave

It owns the mistake without an excuse. A reader can forgive a late van far more easily than a firm that argues about it.

The job needed a callback

Review: Leak came back within a fortnight. Fixed properly on the second visit but I should not have had to chase.

Reply: Thanks for letting us know, Tom. You're right that it should have been done first time, and I'm sorry you had to chase us. Glad it's holding now. If it gives you any more bother, ring me direct on [number]. Dave

The customer has already said it was fixed, so the reply can agree with them. It adds a direct line and leaves out the job's details.

A dispute about the price

Review: Quoted one thing, charged another. Would not use again.

Reply: Sorry you were left unhappy with the bill. We don't like surprises on price either, and I'd like to go through this with you. Please ring me on [number] so we can look at the quote and the invoice together. Dave

It does not put figures in public. Money talk belongs on the phone, and the reader sees a firm willing to open the books.

You disagree with what they say

Review: Left the place in a mess and the work is shoddy.

Reply: Sorry to read this, Neil. That isn't how we leave a job, and it doesn't match what we have on record, so I'd like to come and look at it. Please ring me on [number] and we'll arrange a time. Dave

It disagrees once, politely, and offers to come back. Google says to be honest and only take responsibility for what is actually yours.

You have never heard of them

Review: Worst company in Doncaster. Avoid.

Reply: We take every review seriously, but we can't find a job under this name. If we've worked for you, please ring us on [number] with the address and we'll look into it straight away. Dave

It tells readers there may be no job behind this, without calling anyone a liar. Then report the review, using our guide to removing fake reviews.

The review is abusive

Review: Cowboys. [Owner name] is a crook and I hope you go under.

Reply: We're sorry you feel this way. If you've had a problem with work we did, please ring us on [number] and we'll look into it. Dave

Say nothing about the insults, and report the review for harassment. The reply is there for the next reader, who sees one calm line under an angry post.

One star and no words

Review: (One star, no comment.)

Reply: Sorry you weren't happy. We can't tell which job this was from your review, so if you'd like us to put it right, please ring us on [number]. Dave

There is nothing to answer, so don't guess at what went wrong. One calm line is enough.

What should you never write?

What to leave out of a reply, and why
Leave outWhy
The customer's address, phone number or job detailsGoogle says "Never share the reviewer's private info". Replies are public.
"You're lying" or anything about them as a personGoogle says "Do not attack them personally". It also makes you look worse than the review does.
An offer in return for changing or removing the reviewGoogle treats this as fake engagement and calls it "strictly prohibited".
Deals or promotionsGoogle says reviewers are already customers, so there is no need to offer deals.
A long defence of the job, line by lineGoogle says long replies "might overwhelm" customers. Keep it short.
The same pasted reply on every reviewIt tells the reader nobody read theirs. Google suggests personalising and signing with your name or initials.

Replies have to follow the same policies as reviews, and Google checks them before they go live. If you find yourself writing the reply at 10 o'clock at night, save it and read it again in the morning.

How do you post a reply?

  1. Go to your Business Profile and select Read reviews. You need a verified profile to reply.
  2. Select the Reply icon next to the review.
  3. Write your reply and select Reply.

Google checks it first. That usually takes up to 10 minutes, though Google says it can take up to 30 days. Once approved it appears under the review as a reply from the business, without your personal name, which is why signing it helps.