Which reviews will Google remove?
Google removes reviews that break its content policies. It does not referee arguments: "Google doesn't get involved in conflict between businesses and customers", and it asks you not to report a review "just because you disagree with it or dislike it". So the first job is to work out which kind of bad review you have, because that decides the reason you pick and whether reporting is worth it.
| What you are looking at | Google policy | Report it? |
|---|---|---|
| Someone you have no record of ever working for | Fake engagement: reviews should "reflect a genuine experience" | Yes |
| A competitor, or a former employee | Conflict of interest, which "may include current or former employment" | Worth reporting if you can show the link |
| A complaint about a different firm with a similar name | Off-topic: content must be based on experience at that business | Yes |
| Abuse or threats aimed at you or your staff | Harassment | Yes |
| A review that names a person and posts their details | Personal information | Yes |
| A bad review with a demand for money to remove it | Extortion: Google has a separate report route | Yes, and do not pay |
| A real customer who is being unfair | None | No. Reply to it instead |
The last row is the hard one. If the job happened and the customer is unhappy, expect it to stay up, even if you think they have the facts wrong. Google's own line is that negative reviews "aren't always a sign of poor service".
Check your records before you decide someone was never a customer. People review under a nickname, a partner's account or a business name, so search the job list by street and date as well as by name.
How do you report a fake review?
There are two routes. The quick one is from your Business Profile:
- Go to your Business Profile and select Read reviews.
- Next to the review, select Report.
- Select the reason for flagging it.
- Select Send report.
The second is Google's Reviews Management Tool, and it is the one to use if you have more than one to deal with, because it also shows the status of each report and is where you appeal. Confirm the email address tied to your profile, select your business, then choose Continue, "Report a new review for removal" and Continue. Select Report next to the review, pick the reason in the new tab, and select Submit.
Sign in with the Google account that manages the profile, because the tool works from the email address connected to your Business Profile.
What evidence should you keep?
Google's report steps do not ask for evidence up front, but Which? says Google may ask for proof, and you will need it for an appeal. Save it on the day, because a reviewer can change or delete what they wrote.
- A screenshot of the review showing the reviewer's name, the date and the full text.
- Your job records for that name, street and date, showing nothing matches.
- Anything that links the reviewer to a competitor or a former employee, such as a matching name or a website.
- Messages, if the reviewer has threatened you or asked for money.
Do not send Google a customer's private details to prove a point. Show that the record exists and cover anything personal that the appeal does not need.
What happens after you report it?
Google says flagged reviews that break its policies are removed from Maps and Search, and that evaluation "typically takes several days". You can check progress in the Reviews Management Tool.
| Status | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Decision pending | Flagged, not yet evaluated | Wait |
| Report reviewed, no policy violation | Google checked it and found no breach | Decide whether to use your one appeal |
| Escalated, check your email for updates | The appeal has been escalated | Watch for the final decision by email. If the review broke no rule, it stays live |
How does the appeal work?
If Google finds no violation you can submit what it calls a one-time appeal. In the Reviews Management Tool, select your business, then "Check the status of a review I reported previously and appeal options". At the bottom, select Appeal eligible reviews and choose the reviews, up to 10. Select Continue, then Submit an appeal, and fill in the form. Google removes the review if it breaks the rules and leaves it live if it does not.
It is a one-time appeal, so write it properly. Name the policy, state in a sentence or two why this review breaks it, and say what your records show. "This is unfair" gives Google nothing to act on.
What if the review stays up?
It can happen even when you are sure the review is false. At that point, answer it. A short, calm reply tells the next customer what they need to know, and our example replies for trades include one for someone you never worked for. After that, keep the genuine reviews coming, so that one bad one sits among many.Asking every customer for a review is the long-term answer.
Two things to avoid. Offering anything in return for changing or removing a review is, in Google's words, "fake engagement" and "strictly prohibited". So is answering with fake five-star reviews of your own, which can get your profile restricted and is against UK law. Be careful, too, with anyone who guarantees removal for a fee. Google decides what comes down.
What does UK law say?
Two areas of law can apply. This is general information rather than legal advice, so speak to a solicitor before acting on it.
The first is consumer law. Paragraph 13 of Schedule 20 to the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 bans submitting, or commissioning someone else to submit or write, "a fake consumer review". That can matter if a rival business is behind the review, though you would still need to show it.
The second is defamation, in England and Wales. Section 1 of the Defamation Act 2013 says a statement is not defamatory unless it has caused or is likely to cause serious harm to reputation. For a body that trades for profit, such as a limited company, harm is not "serious harm" unless it has caused or is likely to cause it "serious financial loss". A sole trader may not count as a body, which is a question for your solicitor. Either way, the bar is high and a claim is a last resort.
Google also has a separate route for reporting content you believe breaks the law, and it asks you to flag the content in the product first. It may send a copy of a legal notice to Lumen, a public research database, with your personal contact details redacted, so bear that in mind before you file one.