LoudCrowd sells SEO in Doncaster, so we are one of the firms you might be comparing. Every check below applies to us as much as to anyone else, and the rules come from Google's own pages rather than from us.

Search for SEO in Doncaster and you will find plenty of SEO companies and agencies calling themselves the best, the top or award-winning. None of that tells you whether they will get your phone ringing. What does tell you is how they answer a handful of questions, what they promise, and whose name your Google accounts end up in. Google publishes advice on exactly this, for anyone thinking of hiring help, and this guide works through it for a trade business.

One thing first. Google's own view is that "if you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself." Hiring someone makes sense when your time is worth more on the tools, which for most trades it is. Just go in knowing what a good one looks like.

What should you ask an SEO company before you sign?

Google's page on hiring an SEO suggests interviewing them, and lists the questions to put to them. These are the ones that matter for a local trade, in Google's order, with what to listen for.

Questions from Google's hiring advice, and what a good answer sounds like
QuestionWhat to listen for
Can you show me examples of your previous work?Look for a trade like yours, and request a chat with that client.
Do you follow the Google Search Essentials?These are Google's published rules. Any SEO provider working on your site should know them.
What results do you expect, by when, and how will you measure them?Calls and form enquiries are the measure that pays your bills. Rankings alone are not.
What experience do you have in my industry?A roofer's searches are not a solicitor's searches.
What experience do you have in my town?Find out which local businesses they have worked for, and check those businesses exist.
How long have you been in business?You can check the answer yourself if they are a limited company. See below.
Will you tell me every change you make, and why?The answer should be a plain yes.

Watch whether they ask you anything back. Google says a good SEO should want to know what makes your business unique, who your competitors are and how your customers find you. If they are not interested, its advice is to "find someone who is". It also suggests ringing past clients to find out whether the work was useful, whether the agency was easy to deal with and whether it produced results.

What are the red flags in an SEO pitch?

Most of these come straight from Google. The rest come from the rules Google sets for agencies that look after Business Profiles, the listing that puts you on Maps.

  • A guaranteed first place. "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google," in Google's words. Its rules for agencies list guaranteeing top placement, or promising your profile will show at all times, among the claims they must not make.
  • A special line into Google. Google warns about anyone claiming a "special relationship" with it, or offering a "priority submit". Google never takes money to include or rank sites in its normal results, and paying for Google Ads makes no difference to them either.
  • Charging for the free listing. Business Profile costs nothing. An agency can charge to manage it, but Google says it must tell you in writing, before it starts, that the profile is provided at no extra cost, and show its fee on your invoices. Presenting the free listing as something you pay to be on is on Google's list of misleading claims.
  • A cold email or call saying your site is broken. Google says it gets these too, and suggests treating them like an email about diet pills that burn fat while you sleep. Its rules for SEO agencies also ban excessive cold calls and threats that you will lose your profile unless you sign up.
  • Being asked to link to them. "You should never have to link to an SEO." A credit in your footer is your choice, never a condition.
  • Secrecy. Google says to be careful if a company is secretive or will not explain what it intends to do. You are responsible for what anyone does to your site on your behalf.
  • Submitting you to thousands of directories. Google calls link popularity schemes and mass search engine submission "typically useless exercises".

What should a sound SEO strategy cover?

Google lists the useful services that SEOs and other agencies and consultants provide, including a review of your site's content or structure, technical advice on things like hosting, redirects, error pages and JavaScript, content development, keyword research, and expertise in specific markets. If you are comparing SEO services from more than one provider, a proposal for a trade business should usually cover these, whether it is sold as SEO services by the month or as a one-off project:

  • An SEO audit first. Google says an audit should be about giving you realistic estimates of improvement and an estimate of the work involved, so you know what you are paying for before a monthly fee starts.
  • Technical SEO. Fixing whatever stops pages being found or loading properly: broken links, redirects, slow pages and errors.
  • Keyword research and on-page SEO. Finding the searches your customers actually use, then making sure each service page answers one of them with a clear title, heading and copy.
  • Local SEO. Your Business Profile, reviews and a page for each area you genuinely cover, which matters more to a trade than ranking nationally.
  • Link building, done properly. Links from real local sources such as suppliers, trade bodies and clubs. Google's spam policies list "buying or selling links for ranking purposes" as link spam, so a fixed price for hundreds of links is a warning sign.

Good SEO strategies differ in emphasis, not in these basics, and an expert should be able to explain each one in plain English. If a proposal leaves one out, find out why. If you run an online shop, ecommerce SEO is a different job with its own category and product work, and our sister site loudcrowd.agency covers it.

Who should own your Google accounts?

You should. The profile with all your reviews on it is the one thing here you cannot easily rebuild, so settle who owns it before any work starts.

Your Google Business Profile

Google's third-party rules say that "all end customers must retain ownership or co-ownership of their Business Profile at all times". If an agency sets up your profile, it should make you the owner and itself the manager. If you already have one, it should ask you to invite it as a manager, and nobody should be sharing passwords. Managers can do nearly everything owners can, such as editing your details and replying to reviews. The difference that matters is that only an owner can add or remove people, or delete the profile.

If you stop working with them, Google gives the agency seven working days from your notice to hand back exclusive control and remove its own access. Keeping a profile "hostage in exchange for money" is on Google's list of banned behaviour.

Search Console

Search Console is Google's free tool for seeing how your site does in search. If an agency offers an audit, Google's advice for SEO audits is to give read access only at that stage, not write access. In Search Console terms that means adding them as a user rather than an owner: owners can add and remove people and change settings, users mostly view.

Your website and domain

Google does not cover this, so here is our own advice: make sure the domain name is registered to you and that you can log in to wherever the site is hosted. Settle it before you sign, while everyone is friendly.

How do you check claims like "best", "top", "award-winning" or "No.1"?

Anyone can put those words on a website, so check them before they sway you. These checks work on any of the SEO agencies you are comparing, including us.

  • Look them up on Companies House. If they trade as a limited company, the government's free search shows their registered address, when the company was formed, its current and resigned officers, the documents it has filed, previous company names and any insolvency. You can also set up free email alerts if any of that changes. If they say they have been going for years, this is where you can see it.
  • Check the award with whoever gave it. If a firm calls itself award-winning, find out which award and which year, then look for the winners on the awarding body's own website rather than in a badge on theirs.
  • Ring a reference. Get the number of a business they work for and phone it. Google suggests checking whether the service was useful, whether they were easy to work with and whether the results were positive.
  • Treat "No.1" as a claim about the past at best. Google's own page says "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." Find out what they were first for, where and when, then search it yourself.
  • Read what they say they will do. A proposal you can understand, with the price on it, is a good sign. Our guide to what SEO should cost covers SEO pricing and what the monthly figure should include. Have them explain anything that is unclear, and check whether they back their recommendations with Google's own documentation.

Google also points out that its local rankings are mainly based on relevance, distance and how well known a business is, and that "there's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking". Anyone selling you a shortcut round that is selling something Google says does not exist.

What can you do if an SEO company lets you down?

Start by giving them the chance to put it right, because Google expects you to try that first. If they will not hand back your profile, demand money to keep you listed, or claimed your profile without your permission, Google has a third-party complaint form for reporting SEO agencies and other providers that break its Business Profile rules. Google says it investigates but does not share the outcome, and that it will not get involved in a breach of contract between you and the agency.

If the problem is your website rather than your profile, request the logins and a list of what was changed. Google says an SEO with access to your server "should be willing to explain all the changes they are making to your site".